Most people assume you call a criminal lawyer after you’ve been charged, sometime between the arrest and the first court date. In practice, the people who come out of the system in the best shape are often the ones who called a good deal earlier, sometimes before police had decided to lay a charge at all.
A detective’s business card left in the mailbox, a call from a manager saying the police have asked for the security footage, a friend who mentions that an officer was asking about you. None of these are charges, but each one is a sign that something is under way, and what you do next can shape whether there’s a case and, if there is, how strong it turns out to be.
For anyone in Toronto wondering whether it’s too soon to get advice, the answer from most lawyers at a criminal law firm in Toronto would be that it’s almost never too soon, and frequently too late. These are the moments when it matters most.
When police want to talk to you
This is the single most important moment to call. If an officer asks you to come in for an interview, even in a friendly way, or to give a statement about an incident, speak to a lawyer first. You’re under no obligation to explain yourself, and anything you say in a recorded interview can be used as evidence.
A lawyer can contact the officer for you, find out what the investigation is about, and, if a charge is coming anyway, arrange for you to turn yourself in at a set time. That’s a lot better than being arrested at work in front of your colleagues.
When you’re arrested or detained
Under section 10(b) of the Charter, anyone who’s arrested or detained has the right to speak to a lawyer without delay and to be told about that right. Police must give you a reasonable chance to use it before questioning you. Use it. Ask for a specific lawyer if you have one, or for duty counsel if you don’t, then say nothing about the allegation until you’ve had advice.
If you’re released from the station, the paperwork will set out a court date and often conditions. Read the conditions carefully, because they apply straight away, and breaking one, even by accident, is a separate criminal offence.
Release paperwork sometimes also tells you to attend a police station on a set date to be fingerprinted and photographed. People miss that appointment surprisingly often, usually because it’s in small print and weeks away, and missing it is an offence on its own. A lawyer will spot it on the paperwork and make sure it’s in your calendar.
When someone is being held for bail
If a family member has been arrested and held for a bail hearing, the call to a lawyer should happen the same day. Bail hearings move quickly, often within a day of the arrest, and the outcome depends heavily on preparation, including who can act as a surety, where the person will live, and what conditions might address the court’s concerns. Getting the first hearing right is much easier than reviewing a denial later.
Other moments to pick up the phone
| Situation | Why call now |
| Police executed a search warrant | The warrant and seized items may be challengeable |
| You received a summons | There’s time to prepare before the first appearance |
| You think there’s a warrant out | A lawyer can arrange a planned surrender |
| The Crown offers a deal | You need to know what you’re giving up |
| You’re not a Canadian citizen | A plea can affect your immigration status |
| Your teenager has been charged | Youth cases follow different rules |
The immigration point catches people out more than almost anything else. For permanent residents and people on work or study permits, a plea that seems minor in criminal terms can carry serious immigration consequences, and those consequences need to be weighed before anything is decided in court.
Before you plead guilty to anything
At the first court appearance, it’s tempting to take whatever’s on offer to make the whole thing go away. A guilty plea leaves a criminal record, though, and that record can turn up on background checks for jobs, volunteer work and travel. Many charges can be resolved in other ways, through diversion programs, a peace bond, a withdrawal or a reduced charge, but those outcomes generally come from someone who has read the disclosure and negotiated with the Crown, not from pleading on the first day.
What the first conversation looks like
A first consultation is usually short and confidential. The lawyer will want to know what happened, what paperwork you’ve received and what you’ve already said to police. You should come away understanding the charge or the investigation, the likely next steps and roughly what it would cost to get help.
- Bring any police paperwork.
- Write a timeline before you go.
- List anyone who saw what happened.
- Mention any previous record.
- Ask how fees are charged.
About Legal Solutions Law Firm
Legal Solutions Law Firm was founded by Ryan Manilla, who was called to the Ontario Bar in 2008, and has served clients across the Greater Toronto Area since 2012. Its criminal practice covers impaired driving, assault and domestic assault, theft and fraud, drug and weapons charges, bail hearings and youth matters. The head office is in Scarborough, with appointment-only offices in downtown Toronto, North York, Brampton and Thornhill. The first consultation is free, and phones are answered 24 hours a day.
If you’re reading this because of a business card in your mailbox, that’s exactly the right time to make the call.
This article is general information and isn’t legal advice for any particular case.


